Forgot your password?

Don't have an account? Create An Account

For agents interested in participating on SRX, please contact us at +65 6635 3388 or write to us at


Achieve the life you want, in the home you love
Property News05 Oct 2018

Thomson View fails in fourth bid to sell en bloc

ST 20181005 GLTHOMSON 4326376

Thomson View condo has failed in its fourth attempt to launch a collective sale - just the latest in a growing list of projects that have been unable to secure the requisite 80 per cent approval rate to kick-start a sale.

The 255-unit estate in Upper Thomson Road had raised the reserve price three times in the past year to $938 million, but still garnered backing from only 76 per cent of owners.

This resulted in the sale agreement lapsing on Sept 24, said collective sale committee chairman Tan Kin Lian yesterday.

Thomson View comprises 200 apartments, 54 townhouses and one shop unit on a 540,314 sq ft site.

Townhouse owners would have received around $5.5 million, and apartment owners between $2.6 million and $3.7 million, if the sale had gone through, said Mr Tan, a former chief executive of NTUC Income.

Some owners did not seem bothered about potentially missing out on a bumper payout.

One resident who wanted to be known only as Mrs Lai said that she was not too upset about the failed attempt.

"I supported the en bloc because the price was pretty attractive," noted Mrs Lai, who is in her 40s and married with two children.

"I really love this place. The house is spacious - 2,000 sq ft. It's hard to find a space that big."

The stamp duty payable proved a deterrent for some owners, said Mr Tan, while a number also resisted because they did not agree with the apportionment method.

"Others liked living at Thomson View," he added.

But for Mrs Lai, even though she would have had to pay the sellers' stamp duty because she has lived in the estate for only two years, "the projected gains were more than enough to cover it and pay for a new home".

Mr Tan believes the biggest challenge was that owners who signed the sale agreement would have been liable to contribute towards legal costs if the sale were to be challenged in court again.

Many of them became "wiser" after they were hit by large legal bills incurred in the last attempt to sell en bloc, in 2013, he added.

Back then, a proposed $590 million collective sale was voided after the High Court found that former marketing agent HSR International Realtors had offered incentive payments to four owners to get them to sign the sale agreement.

It was earlier reported that 215 unit owners at Thomson View had agreed to the collective sale in 2013, and their legal costs had been in the six-figure range.

Mr Tan noted yesterday: "Why should legal fees for an unsuccessful sale be borne only by the signing owners?

"That encourages some owners to become free riders, meaning they want others to be signing owners because they don't want to incur legal fees themselves if the sale gets challenged in court again."

Mr Tan suggested that a fairer approach would be for the collective sale agreement to state "that in the event of a successful sale, a certain percentage of the total sales proceeds, not exceeding 0.5 per cent, may be set aside to be distributed among the signing owners for the risk that they have taken".

Like this article? Share it.
mySG Home
Your Digital Home
Track Your Home. Discover Your Wealth
The free, personalized advice, advocacy, and guidance for buying or renting property in Singapore
Property News 11 December
Park View Mansions tries for en bloc again with 22% lower reserve price
Park View Mansions will relaunch on Wednesday its collective sale tender with a 22 per cent lower reserve price than before, making it the latest case of owners dialling down their expectations amid a quieter en bloc market.
Property News 10 December
Recommended by Stanley Street shophouse up for sale
A freehold shophouse at 28 Stanley Street has been put up for sale in an expression of interest exercise.
Property News 05 December
Sysma Holdings clinches $18.6m contract to build two-storey Good Class Bungalow
The existing seven-bedroom house, which was vacant when it was bought, has a built-up area of some 11,000 sq ft, with two floors, an attic and a swimming pool.
Property News 06 December
Singapore's premium office space seen to be cost effective
Demand for office rental remains strong in Singapore. The office rental index for the central region rose 2.5 per cent in the three months to Sept 30 over the second quarter, based on data from the Urban Redevelopment Authority.

Contact Us

Hello Singapore! I'm Sevi. Ask me any property question.
Chat with Sevi
Sevi - AI Bot
Replies in seconds
Need to speak to someone? 6635-3388
I'm Sevi, your personal assistant.

You can ask me basic property questions about transactions, listings, project info and X-value.

Some Examples:

1. Where is Gem Residences located?
2. Are there listings in Hillview Regency for 3 bedrooms and budget of $1.5m?
3. For how much can I sell my property?
4. What are the latest transactions in Bayshore Park?
5. Is it cheaper to buy HDB in Tampines or Jurong East?
6. What is the plot ratio for The Sail?
7. How many blocks are there in Ang Mo Kio Ave 3?

Type RESET or HELP whenever you need.